Here’s a structured rating and analysis of the three brands—Polène, DEMELLIER, and JIL SANDER—based on design, craftsmanship, brand ethos, market positioning, and overall appeal:

---

1. Polène

Rating: 8.5/10
Strengths:

• Design: Clean, sculptural silhouettes with Parisian minimalism. Signature details like twisted knots and textured leathers make their bags Instagram-famous.

• Accessibility: Positioned as "accessible luxury," offering premium quality at mid-range prices (€200–€500).

• Craftsmanship: Handmade in Spain, leveraging Ubrique’s leatherworking heritage. Solid quality for the price point.

• Digital Savvy: Strong social media presence, appealing to millennials and Gen Z.

Weaknesses:

• Sustainability: Less emphasis on eco-initiatives compared to DEMELLIER.

• Exclusivity: Mass appeal via direct-to-consumer model may dilute luxury perception over time.

---

2. DEMELLIER

Rating: 8.0/10
Strengths:

• Ethical Focus: Prioritizes sustainability (vegan leather, carbon-neutral shipping) and ethical production in Europe.

• Timeless Design: Classic shapes with modern twists, appealing to conscious consumers seeking longevity.

• Luxury Positioning: Priced slightly above Polène (€300–€700), targeting the contemporary luxury segment.

• Retail Partnerships: Sold through premium platforms like Net-a-Porter and Harrods, enhancing credibility.

Weaknesses:

• Brand Recognition: Less viral than Polène, with a smaller social media footprint.

• Design Innovation: More conservative compared to Polène’s sculptural boldness.

---

3. JIL SANDER

Rating: 9.5/10
Strengths:

• Heritage & Prestige: A pillar of minimalist luxury since 1968, synonymous with avant-garde tailoring and intellectual design.

• Craftsmanship: Produced in Italy with premium materials (e.g., Japanese wool, Italian calfskin), representing pinnacle luxury.

• Brand Equity: Part of the OTB Group (Maison Margiela, Marni), ensuring high-fashion credibility and global retail networks.

• Sustainability: Aligns with OTB’s "Be Brave, Be Responsible" initiative, focusing on eco-materials and supply chain transparency.

Weaknesses:

• Price Point: Ultra-luxury pricing (€1,000+ for bags, €2,000+ for apparel) limits accessibility.

• Niche Appeal: Minimalist austerity may not resonate with consumers seeking bold logos or trends.

---

Final Rankings

1. JIL SANDER (9.5/10): The gold standard for minimalist luxury, blending heritage, craftsmanship, and high-fashion prestige.

2. Polène (8.5/10): A disruptor in accessible luxury, winning with photogenic design and savvy digital marketing.

3. DEMELLIER (8.0/10): Ethically driven and timeless, but slightly overshadowed in innovation and brand recognition.

---

Key Takeaways

• For Investment Pieces: JIL SANDER’s timeless designs justify its premium.

• For Trend-Conscious Buyers: Polène offers Instagrammable quality at approachable prices.

• For Ethical Shoppers: DEMELLIER balances sustainability with understated elegance.

Each brand excels in its niche, catering to distinct audiences within the luxury landscape. 👜✨

← OTB to equip Jil Sander, Marni, Maison Margiela products with digital authenticity certificate
→ 1.polene 2.DEMELLIER 3.JIL SANDER Which of these three brands is more popular among young people?